July 14, 2018 at 7:00 PM EDT

Joshua Williams

Defender

Jonathan Mensah

Defender

Wil Trapp

Midfielder

Artur

Midfielder

Pedro Santos

Midfielder

Gyasi Zardes

Attacker

Zack Steffen

Goalkeeper

Harrison Afful

Defender

Niko Hansen

Attacker

Ricardo Clark

Midfielder

Mike Grella

Attacker

Héctor Jiménez

Midfielder

Lalas Abubakar

Defender

Eduardo Sosa

Attacker

Jon Kempin

Goalkeeper

Luis Argudo

Midfielder

Richard Gamache

Assistant #1

Jeffrey Greeson

Assistant #2

Nima Saghafi

Fourth Official

20 minutes

Jonathan Mensah of the Columbus Crew received a Yellow Card

36 minutes

Gyasi Zardes of the Columbus Crew received a Yellow Card

55 minutes

Rónald Matarrita of the New York City subistitued out of the game and Jon Lewis substituted in

60 minutes

Niko Hansen of the Columbus Crew subistitued out of the game and Mike Grella substituted in

65 minutes

Rodney Wallace of the New York City subistitued out of the game and Kwame Awuah substituted in

70 minutes

Pedro Santos of the Columbus Crew subistitued out of the game and Eduardo Sosa substituted in

78 minutes

Federico Higuaín of the Columbus Crew subistitued out of the game and Luis Argudo substituted in

80 minutes

Jesús Medina of the New York City scored goal assisted by Jon Lewis

82 minutes

Mike Grella of the Columbus Crew received a Yellow Card

85 minutes

Jesús Medina of the New York City subistitued out of the game and Sebastien Ibeagha substituted in

90 minutes

Anton Tinnerholm of the New York City scored goal

3 seconds

Eduardo Sosa of the Columbus Crew minutes in extra time received a Red Card