September 1, 2018 at 8:00 PM EDT

Jonathan Mensah

Defender

Wil Trapp

Midfielder

Pedro Santos

Midfielder

Artur

Midfielder

Justin Meram

Attacker

Gyasi Zardes

Attacker

Lalas Abubakar

Defender

Zack Steffen

Goalkeeper

Harrison Afful

Defender

Ricardo Clark

Midfielder

Joshua Williams

Defender

Héctor Jiménez

Midfielder

Jon Kempin

Goalkeeper

Luis Argudo

Midfielder

Niko Hansen

Attacker

Patrick Mullins

Attacker

Sean Johnson

Goalkeeper

Anton Tinnerholm

Defender

Maxime Chanot

Defender

David Villa

Attacker

Alexander Ring

Midfielder

Maxi Moralez

Attacker

Thomas McNamara

Midfielder

Rodney Wallace

Attacker

Ismael Tajouri

Midfielder

Ben Sweat

Defender

Kwame Awuah

Defender

Jon Lewis

Midfielder

Daniel Bedoya

Midfielder

Joseph Scally

Defender

Brad Stuver

Goalkeeper

Alan Kelly

Referee

Adam Wienckowski

Assistant #1

Nick Uranga

Assistant #2

Nima Saghafi

Fourth Official

45 minutes

Rodney Wallace of the New York City received a Yellow Card

46 minutes

Rodney Wallace of the New York City subistitued out of the game and Ben Sweat substituted in

53 minutes

Ismael Tajouri of the New York City scored goal assisted by Anton Tinnerholm

61 minutes

Harrison Afful of the Columbus Crew scored goal

63 minutes

Justin Meram of the Columbus Crew scored goal assisted by Pedro Santos

67 minutes

Thomas McNamara of the New York City subistitued out of the game and Valentín Castellanos substituted in

67 minutes

Ben Sweat of the New York City received a Yellow Card

75 minutes

Sebastien Ibeagha of the New York City received a Yellow Card

79 minutes

Rónald Matarrita of the New York City subistitued out of the game and Jon Lewis substituted in

89 minutes

Federico Higuaín of the Columbus Crew subistitued out of the game and Joshua Williams substituted in

3 seconds

Alexander Ring of the New York City minutes in extra time received a Yellow Card

5 seconds

Justin Meram of the Columbus Crew minutes in extra time subistitued out of the game and Luis Argudo substituted in